128-Bit Essence

"128-Bit Essence" explores the evolving interplay between human-, mass media-, and AI-generated representations through two units of analysis in the ethnographers’ toolkit - “Place” and “Person.” The installation consists of 64 artifacts each – representing Santa Monica and a single ethnographic informant, respectively – organized into two 8x8 grids. In lieu of an ethnographer’s narrative structure, the grids, mirroring the spatial organization of ‘bits’ in computing, flatten the artifacts’ relationships to one another and traditional hierarchies between human- and AI-generated materials.  

Representation is core to ethnographic theory and practice. This installation challenges us to reconsider how ethnography and ethnographic objects of study are increasingly mediated by a range of new representational technologies, in particular Generative AI. The interplay of representations conjures what Malinowski termed “the imponderability of actual life,” the uncomfortable and political space between what we can represent and life as it is lived. Rather than resolving that tension, we invite you to critique, embrace, reject, and engage with the incongruencies and vulnerability that come with ethnographic representation. 

In conversation with the EPIC 2024 themes of Foundation, Generation, and Displacement, we use visual representation to show how technologies can generate new ways of seeing by displacing old conventions, while at times reinforcing tropes and associations. As you walk through this space, we invite you to critique and embrace the incongruencies that come with representation, simultaneously a source of tension and a part of who and where we are as ethnographers. 

This piece was prepared as a physical installation for the EPIC 2024 conference in Los Angeles. The online format differs from the physical, but has been provided to enable further information on the images included, available by clicking on individual images.

Place

“Place” explores (versions of) Santa Monica, home to the EPIC 2024 conference. Photos of Santa Monica train AI models to portray this place, which in turn trains us humans as new vehicles for documentation and data gathering, completing the endless cycle of (re)presenting. The result is a piece that lives on a tenuous line between perception and stereotype, truth and humor, fact and fiction, subjective experience and universal abstraction. The piece functions as a simulacrum: a copy of a place that has no original source.  

For the two artists, one of them a native Angeleno and the other never having been to Santa Monica, triangulating between different modes of mediation was a way to (re)discover Santa Monica. To generate the installation, one of the artists drew from personal experiences of Santa Monica while the other inhabited the vantage point of AI itself by experiencing Santa Monica solely through digital media, finding and producing images that aim to on the one hand represent the familiar and on the other hand discover the unfamiliar.  

As AI systems mediate our work and our world further, we are forced to reckon with our own experiences of Santa Monica: Is it the wide car lanes and beautiful sunsets? Is it the dinosaurs roaming empty promenades or crystallized as fountains? Is it the messy overlaps of people, buildings, and the photographers’ gaze? 

Person

"Person” takes the process of ethnographic representation and turns it on its head: the text of fieldnotes from an ethnographic encounter is used to generate a synthetic set of images representing a single informant’s struggles with air pollution. We see 64 representations of ‘Franck’ – a Martinique-born Parisian, father of two, avid runner, and transport manager – filtered through multiple layers of interpretation and representation, from the ethnographer to GPT4 to Midjourney to the artists. 

While they fail as portraits – Franck is physically never the same – these representations take us into Franck’s everyday realities and to impossible places – episodes in his past, distant places outside the ethnographer’s reach, his dreams. In composite, they are a powerful affective portrait of how Franck encounters a polluted world: the experiences that shaped him, his anxieties and nervous habits, and his efforts to cope. 

Yet these representations also obscure his experiences. To ‘paint a picture’ of his life, they rely on pastiche, collapsing familiar corners into globally famous landscapes; they misrepresent his physical self and race; they over-dramatize subtle or ambiguous experiences with established styles and iconography. The ethnographer’s eye for the complexity of everyday life is lost. 

While some are absurd misunderstandings or hallucinations, many are gaps in precision met with leaps in interpretation, or gaps in data met with unknowing substitutions. As we collaborate more with AI systems, is this affective essence enough? Will we need greater ethnographic precision to make AI tools useful? Will models need to map the world better to reflect an ethnographer’s nuance?